pie & pastry

The best dang pie since your great-grandma's cast iron stove.

Pre-Order Here

Order Online

Update for 2025!!
The Williamsville Farmer Market on Saturdays.
The Kenmore Farmer Market on Sundays.
The Amherst Market at Bassett Park on 6/8, 7/13, 8/10, 9/14.

Blueberry Pie

Grandma Apple Pie

New

Coconut Pie

Order Online

Bill Reilly.

“They were all really delicious but that coconut pie was something special."

Joanna.

"OMG, the coconut pie was so amazing!!."

Liz.

“it was incredible!! So impressed!!! I’m a baker and I used to make pies many moons ago. This was far better than anything I ever made!.”

About Our Pie

Our fruit mini-pies start with a family pie dough recipe that has been enjoyed for generations. The crust is perfectly flakey and tender with a hint of butter up front, but then it stands aside to showcase our sweet, fresh and robust homemade fruit fillings.

Prohibition Pie's seasonal selections

We think that the shortest distance from farm to mouth results in the best pie experience for you. Of course, this is Buffalo, and so with a short growing season our excitement focuses on offering those limited fresh seasonal pie flavors, while always maintaining our core menu of the classics.

You can look forward to seasonal selections like peach, strawberry rhubarb, apricot peach, blueberry and more.

Shop Now